Privacy Bill Sponsors Pull Legislation Over Cornyn Amendment

Sens. Mike Lee (R-Utah) and Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) pulled a popular email privacy bill from a Judiciary Committee markup Thursday, due to a controversial amendment they say would excessively expand the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s surveillance power.

Leahy, the top Democrat on the committee, said the provision from Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) is a “poison pill amendment that will tank this otherwise popular bill.”

Cornyn’s amendment would give the director of the FBI, or someone acting in the same capacity, the ability to force a provider to hand over data, without a warrant, detailing a suspect’s name, physical address, email address, phone number, device serial number, login history and length of service with a provider, among other identifiable information. It would allow the FBI to get that information through a separate administrative subpoena in a process known as “national security letters.”

The amendment was offered to a bill updating the 1986 Electronic Communications Privacy Act, which would require law enforcement to obtain a warrant before compelling the content of an online communication stored more than 180 days or on a cloud service. Lee, the bill’s sponsor, and Leahy have spent five years pushing for this update, which they and other privacy advocates say is a common-sense change to an outdated law. After the House unanimously passed companion legislation in late April, advocates thought their long-fought battle might be nearing an end.

Cornyn offered his controversial amendment just before a Senate Judiciary Committee markup of the ECPA in May. Instead of considering the amendment, Lee and Leahy held the bill. Today they pulled the legislation entirely.

“Unfortunately, some senators on the committee have decided, late in the day, that this bill should be a vehicle to move an unrelated and controversial expansion of the use of national security letters by the FBI,” Lee said at the markup. “While there are other concerns we had hoped to negotiate, the national security letter amendment is something I cannot in good conscience have attached to this bill.”

Cornyn fought back at Leahy’s characterization of the amendment as a “poison pill,” saying his amendment would be adopted if allowed a vote.

“It strikes me as odd,” Cornyn said. “I believe the amendment enjoys the support of the majority of this committee.”

Cornyn argued that civil liberties concerns are overblown because the FBI would merely get metadata, such as IP addresses or other personal information, that is necessary and “highly targeted” by counterterrorism officials. Law enforcement says this practice is already legal and merely fixes a “typo” in the original law. The policy is a top priority for FBI Director James Comey and is supported by the White House.

But Lee disagreed.

“The fact that it’s just metadata does not dismiss the problems associated with telephone metadata,” Lee said.  “The government could tell a whole lot about you by virtue of who you call, who called you, how long you talked.”

“If it’s so necessary and so non-controversial, find another vehicle or let it run on its own, but don’t attach it to this bill when we spent years developing with a broad-based, bipartisan bicameral coalition,” Lee added.

The tech community opposes Cornyn’s amendment because of the lack of judicial approval or oversight. On Monday, tech companies Facebook and Google joined groups such as the American Civil Liberties Union and the Center for Democracy and Technology to send a letter to senators opposing the Cornyn amendment.


Tech Brief: Lobbying Tech Groups Target NAFTA Renegotiations

According to data from the Center for Responsive Politics, the number of tech companies and trade associations registered to lobby U.S., Canadian and Mexican government officials has more than doubled in the last few months. Companies like Cisco Systems Inc. and Microsoft Corp. are looking to zero out tariffs for tech goods and remove restrictions on cloud storage as officials prepare to renegotiate the North American Free Trade Agreement.

Tech Brief: Intel CEO Leaves Trump’s Manufacturing Council

Brian Krzanich, Intel Corp.’s chief executive, joined the chief executives of Merck and Under Armour in announcing that he would leave Trump’s council on American manufacturing following the president’s response to violence during a white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Va. Krzanich said he resigned “to call attention to the serious harm our divided political climate is causing to critical issues.” 

Tech Brief: Week in Review & What’s Ahead

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit will not block the Federal Communications Commission’s April decision to eliminate price caps for much of the business broadband market. The FCC’s business data services ruling deems certain local markets as competitive, even when there is only one broadband service provider.

Tech Brief: Benchmark Capital Sues Former Uber CEO Kalanick

Benchmark Capital is suing Uber Technologies Inc.’s co-founder and former CEO Travis Kalanick for not honoring the terms of his resignation and allegedly trying to stack the company’s board with allies to prepare for a return as CEO. The Silicon Valley venture firm, one of Uber’s biggest shareholders, alleges that Kalanick is attempting to “entrench himself for his own selfish ends” — an accusation a Kalanick spokesman called “without merit.”

Tech Brief: Kaspersky Lab, Microsoft Reach Antitrust Resolution

Cybersecurity firm Kaspersky Lab plans to withdraw antitrust complaints it made in Europe against Microsoft Corp. after the U.S. tech company agreed to work with outside antivirus vendors on delivery of its security updates for Windows users. The Moscow-based security company in June accused Microsoft of abusing its dominance in the computer market by favoring its own antivirus software over those of independent security companies.

Tech Brief: SoftBank Considers U.S. Ride-Hailing Investment

SoftBank Group Corp.’s founder and CEO, Masayoshi Son, publicly expressed interest in branching out into the U.S. ride-hailing market by investing in Uber Technologies Inc. or Lyft Inc. SoftBank has funded Uber’s competitors in China, India and Southeast Asia, but last month reports came out that the company was looking at buying a stake in Uber.

Tech Brief: Week in Review & What’s Ahead

Apple Inc. agreed to remove virtual private network applications from its app stores in China. The Chinese government has been bolstering its “great firewall,” which blocks access to many, mostly foreign, websites — a firewall that VPNs could circumvent. The company defended its actions, saying it complies with the law in every country, but is facing public backlash for giving into China’s censorship demands.

Load More