Stakeholders Diverge on Effects of Looming Net Neutrality Change

Ahead of Thursday’s Federal Communications Commission procedural vote aimed at repealing net neutrality rules adopted in 2015, opposing stakeholders are focusing on its potential economic effects. Not surprisingly they’re reaching starkly different conclusions.

The proposal, which guts the legal framework of the two-year-old rules and asks if any regulations are even necessary, will officially be opened for public comment on Thursday after a vote by the three-member FCC (which has two open seats). This will start the process to roll back the Obama-era regulation.

FCC Chairman Ajit Pai and other supporters of the change contend the current rules, which classify broadband providers as a “common carrier” similar to telephone companies, have hampered internet investment and innovation. He argued in an April speech in Washington that among the nation’s 12 largest internet service providers, “domestic broadband capital expenditures decreased by 5.6 percent, or $3.6 billion, between 2014 and 2016.”

But a study by Free Press, a pro-net neutrality group, says net neutrality rules in place now have actually produced an overall increase in investment.

That study differs from conclusions reached by the trade group U.S. Telecom, which backs Pai’s plan to reduce the government’s oversight of high-speed internet providers.

Via email, a spokeswoman for U.S. Telecom attributed at least some of the difference to Free Press’ inclusion of investments she said were not reflective of improvements to U.S. networks. That includes investments in Mexico and a phone-leasing program that Sprint sprung for.

However the numbers shake out there, Christopher Hooton, chief economist for the Internet Association, which represents more than 40 big-name internet companies like Google and Twitter, takes issue with the reliance on blanket capital expenditures alone.

“No one statistic proves anything,” he said on a teleconference with the media to release his own study. “ISP claims of depressed investment simply do not mesh with reality.”

The Internet Association report looked at investments specific to telecommunication infrastructure to show an increase of $77 billion in the area between 2009 and 2016.

In yet another study assessing the impact of Title II classification on investment, the Phoenix Center for Advanced Legal & Economic Public Policy Studies says even if you break down capital expenditures to more specific parts, you have to look for the “counterfactuals.” In other words, investment may have increased, but research shouldn’t discount the extent to which there might have been even larger increases if it weren’t for looming Title II reclassification.

With data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, Phoenix Center’s chief economist George Ford explained in a teleconference that using data from comparative sectors he determined most closely matched the spending patterns of the communication industry over multiple decades — in this case, the manufacturing and transportation — to note any difference when Title II entered the conversation. In this way, he suggests a loss of $30 to $40 billion annually in telecommunication investments due to the threat of a title II classification.

Update: This story has been updated to clarify Christopher Hooton’s comments.


Tech Brief: 3 House Democrats Call for FCC Investigation of Sputnik

Three Democratic members of the House Energy and Commerce Committee called on the Federal Communications Commission to investigate whether Sputnik, a news organization established by a Russian state-owned news agency, violated the public interest standard of its broadcast license with its radio show. Reps. Anna Eshoo (Calif.), Frank Pallone Jr. (N.J.) and Mike Doyle (Pa.) asked FCC Chairman Ajit Pai to follow up on a New York Times Magazine report that suggested the organization used U.S. airwaves to broadcast programming aimed at influencing the outcome of the 2016 U.S. presidential election.

Tech Brief: FCC Requests More Information on Sinclair-Tribune Merger

The Federal Communications Commission asked Sinclair Broadcast Group to provide more information on its proposal to acquire Tribune Media Co., a merger currently pending FCC approval. The FCC’s Media Bureau chief wrote a letter to Sinclair asking the telecommunications company to present further information about the size of its current audience, as well as the steps the company plans to take to stay below the ownership cap.

Tech Brief: Kaspersky Agrees to Testify Before House Committee

The House Science, Space and Technology Committee invited Kaspersky Lab Inc. co-founder and CEO Eugene Kaspersky to testify, along with other private and U.S. government cybersecurity experts, before the panel on Sept. 27, and he accepted the invitation — pending the acquisition of an expedited visa. The Moscow-based company, which makes antivirus software, is on the defensive from allegations it aids Russian espionage efforts.

Tech Brief: Judges Rule Uber-Waymo Case Will Go to Trial, Not Arbitration

A panel for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit denied Uber Technologies Inc.’s appeal request for its legal dispute with Waymo LLC to move to private arbitration and ruled a public trial will proceed as scheduled in October. The court also ruled that Uber must hand over a crucial report for Waymo’s case that could hold evidence Uber stole trade secrets related to the development of self-driving cars.

Tech Brief: House Democrats Request Answers From Equifax on Data Breach

Led by Rep. Frank Pallone Jr. (D-N.J.), all 24 Democrats on the House Energy and Commerce Committee sent a letter to Equifax Inc. CEO Richard Smith expressing concerns that it took more than a month for the company to reveal the massive data breach it said took place from mid-May through July, and about the scale and extent of the breach. The signers asked Smith to address these concerns prior to a planned hearing on the issue.

Tech Brief: Apple Expected to Unveil Premium Model ‘iPhone X’ Today

Apple Inc. plans to premiere the so-called iPhone X with a starting price of $999.00 at a 10th anniversary iPhone event on Tuesday, joining Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd in the market for luxury smartphones. In addition to the iPhone X, which uses infrared facial recognition to unlock the device, Apple is also expected to release cheaper models of the iPhone and an updated Apple Watch, with self-contained connect

Tech Brief: Two House Committees Call Hearings on Equifax Data Breach

Equifax Ltd. could be examined by up to three committees in the U.S. House of Representatives after a breach at the company exposed the data of roughly 143 million people. Chairman Jeb Hensarling (R-Texas) of the Financial Services Committee and Chairman Greg Walden (R-Ore.) of the Energy and Commerce Committee announced hearings, and Rep. Ted Lieu (D-Calif.) called for an investigation by the Judiciary Committee.

Load More