ISPs Have Their Own Definition of Net Neutrality

Internet service providers have been among the fiercest critics of the Federal Communications Commission’s two-year-old net neutrality rules aimed at preventing companies like Verizon Communications Inc. and Comcast Corp. from dictating how fast — or slow — online content can be accessed.

That doesn’t mean ISPs oppose net neutrality — they just have a different definition for it, Comcast Senior Executive Vice President David Cohen said Wednesday during a panel discussion in Washington. Cohen endorsed the recent FCC move that begins reversing Obama-era rules that classified the internet as a “utility” under Title II of the Communications Act of 1934.

“Getting rid of Title II does not mean getting rid of net neutrality,” Cohen said at Free State Foundation’s telecommunications policy conference. “You can support net neutrality rules, but you don’t have to do that under all of the baggage that comes with Title II.”

That approach is shared by FCC Chairman Ajit Pai, who warned at Wednesday’s conference about market uncertainty due to Title II classification. Pai said the rules — known as the Open Internet order — stifle telecom investments in expanding and improving broadband services.

“They need to know that the rules aren’t going to change based on who had what for breakfast,” Pai said.

Broadband providers contend that under the current rules, ISPs will eventually be regulated like utilities.

Robert W. Quinn Jr., AT&T Inc.’s senior executive vice president for external and legislative affairs, said at the conference that the industry was told during the Obama administration that “there wouldn’t be rate regulation, but it was just a matter of time before we saw rate regulation.”

“We saw movement toward limiting free data,” he added.

Quinn was referring to “zero rating” programs in which ISPs don’t charge customers for data used on video streaming services that they own, such as T-Mobile’s Binge On. Many net neutrality advocates consider that practice a violation of the principle of equal internet access because it gives preferential treatment to one service over another competing service. Shortly after the Open Internet order was issued, advocates note, then-FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler called for an investigation of such practices.

Meredith Attwell Baker, president and chief executive of the Cellular and Telecommunications Industry Association, echoed the need for marketplace predictability by calling for legislation.

“I’m optimistic that we’re closer to coming up with rules we can all agree on and hopefully we can get Congress to enact these rules so we can stop the ping-ponging” between administrations, Baker said at Wednesday’s conference.

Senate Commerce Committee Chairman John Thune (R-S.D.) has said that one of his priorities for the 115th Congress is drafting bipartisan legislation that would codify certain principles that base the idea of net neutrality into law, such as the prohibition of paid prioritization and blocking and throttling online content.

But Cohen and others at the conference voiced discomfort with outright banning of paid prioritization as part of a net neutrality effort. In response to a question about barriers to a potential compromise, Cohen said “there’s disagreement about paid prioritization.”

Briefings

Tech Brief: White House Supports FCC’s Net Neutrality Repeal

The White House weighed in on the net neutrality debate, with deputy press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders issuing a statement in support of Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai’s plan to roll back rules instituted by the 2015 Open Internet Order. President Donald Trump stopped short of filing comments with the FCC on the matter, but Sanders said that the issue should be resolved through congressional legislation.

Tech Brief: Internet Association Asks FCC to Keep Net Neutrality

The Internet Association, a group that represents major tech companies including Alphabet Inc. and Facebook Inc., is officially calling on the Federal Communications Commission to keep net neutrality rules in place. In comments filed with the agency, the Internet Association noted that a net neutrality repeal could cause damage to the markets and limit innovation.

Tech Brief: House Bill Requires Pentagon to Report Russian Hacking

House lawmakers voted to advance an amendment to the 2018 National Defense Authorization Act that would require the Pentagon to report attempts by Russian hackers to break into its network. The amendment was approved by the full House, and comes amid heightened concerns regarding Kremlin-backed cyberattacks and hacks that have targeted the United States and its allies across the world.

Tech Brief: AT&T Joins Net Neutrality ‘Day of Action’

AT&T Inc. announced that it will participate in today’s internet-wide Day of Action to Save Net Neutrality, despite supporting Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai’s proposal to roll back the 2015 Open Internet Order. An AT&T executive wrote a blog post saying that the wireless provider wanted to show its support for “preserving and advancing an open internet.”

Tech Brief: Microsoft Plans to Expand Rural Broadband Using ‘White Space’

Microsoft Corp. President Brad Smith is expected to announce support for TV white-space technology, which the company says is a frugal way to tap into unused television bandwidth and bring broadband access to rural communities. The company will also reportedly work with rural telecommunications companies on at least 12 projects in 12 states over the next two years to bring broadband connectivity to at least 2 million rural Americans by July 2022.

Load More