By Eli Yokley
April 21, 2021 at 6:00 am ET
Among the 28% who are undecided about D.C. statehood, arguments about its size relative to other states and the fact that its residents pay federal taxes appear to be the most persuasive.
74% of D.C. statehood’s opponents argue that it was never meant to be a state.
More voters – including 1 in 4 opponents of D.C. statehood – support making Puerto Rico a state.
The House is set to vote this week to make the District of Columbia the 51st state for the second time in as many years, giving statehood advocates what may feel like momentum. But outside the confines of the House Democratic Caucus, polling shows public support for admitting the would-be state of “Washington, Douglass Commonwealth” into the union is lukewarm at best.
According to a new Morning Consult/Politico poll, 40 percent of voters — including 62 percent of Democrats — support D.C. statehood, while 32 percent oppose it, including 59 percent of Republicans.
Roughly 3 in 10 voters, fueled largely by independents, are undecided on the question, suggesting ample room for persuasion as the issue faces near-certain demise in the Senate due in part to the legislative filibuster. The survey, conducted April 16-19 among 1,992 registered voters, posed a number of arguments both for and against statehood in order to gauge what contentions could sway voters.
Among those who were undecided about whether to admit D.C. as a state, about a quarter each identified the fact that residents of the district pay federal taxes without having voting representation in Congress and that its population is larger than those of two current states, Vermont and Wyoming, as reasons to support statehood.
On Capitol Hill, Republicans have cast D.C. statehood as a cynical Democratic effort to grab two new Senate seats, given the U.S. capital city’s overwhelming electoral bent toward the party: In November, 92 percent of D.C. voters backed President Joe Biden, whose administration endorsed the statehood legislation on Tuesday.
“The ramifications are mind-boggling with two new Senate seats,” Rep. James Comer (R-Ky.) said Tuesday during a House Rules Committee hearing on H.R. 51. “I wonder if we would even be having this discussion if Joe Manchin were going along with everything – if he’d agree to end the filibuster.”
Among Republican elected officials, partisan arguments often take precedence over those framed around the city’s small population compared to many other states or originalist arguments regarding its proximity to federal power and the Founding Fathers’ initial intentions of independence for the District.
But the poll finds evidence that those originalist arguments resonate more deeply with statehood opponents in the electorate than those of the partisan variety: 3 in 4 voters who oppose statehood said Congress should not grant it because D.C. was never meant to be a state, while just 17 percent framed their opposition on the grounds that the move would help Democrats.
Democratic Rep. Jamie Raskin, a proponent of statehood who represents a Maryland district that borders the capital, said the push to admit Washington into the union is part of a long “trajectory of political inclusion” for Americans, and suggested there might be room for compromise between the two parties in coupling statehood for the District with the admission of Puerto Rico, an American territory whose ratification as a U.S. state was supported by the latest version of the Republican Party’s platform.
“Maybe there’s the ingredients for some real-life bipartisanship,” Raskin said Tuesday. “We’ve got one party who’s been arguing for statehood for these people, another arguing for statehood for these people – let’s put it together and make democracy work.”
Roughly a quarter of Republican voters (26 percent) support statehood for Puerto Rico, 10 percentage points higher than the share who support the status for the District of Columbia, though a majority (52 percent) still oppose the idea. While Democrats support statehood for both places equally, independent voters are 9 points more likely to support Puerto Rico statehood than to back making D.C. a state, 40 percent to 31 percent.
Overall, 45 percent of voters support Puerto Rico statehood, and among those who oppose statehood for D.C., 24 percent said they would support the introduction of the Caribbean island into the union.