The Internal Revenue Service recently said it would offer taxpayers an alternative way to verify their identities that doesn’t require facial recognition to access their online IRS accounts, following pushback from privacy advocates and some lawmakers. But a new Morning Consult/Politico survey found that registered voters are nearly divided in their support for the federal government’s use of facial recognition for account verification.
What the numbers say
- Forty-five percent of voters said they opposed the government’s use of facial recognition for citizens to access their online accounts, while 39 percent said they favored it.
- Half of Republicans said they are opposed to the government’s use of facial recognition technology to access services, while 47 percent of Democrats said they supported it.
- Federal and state agencies were looking to increasingly use facial recognition technology to let users access programs like unemployment insurance, pandemic assistance grants and tax credits, with private contractor ID.me helping those agencies to do so.
- But 85 percent of voters in the survey reported never having used facial recognition technology to access government services, even as it has been used by a variety of federal agencies including the Veterans Affairs and Labor departments, as well as in more than 20 states.
What it means
The expanded use of facial recognition technology has raised the hackles of privacy advocates. The criticism prompted the IRS to announce it would offer a live virtual interview for users’ identity verification instead. ID.me also said it would drop its facial recognition requirement for all its government clients and offer alternative methods of verification.
The initial IRS plan to use facial recognition technology created a firestorm of criticism among lawmakers, too.
Rep. Bill Huizenga (R-Mich.) introduced a bill that would ban the IRS from collecting any biometric data, while a slew of other elected officials from both sides of the aisle sent letters to the agency questioning its plans to use facial recognition and calling on it to abandon them. In a statement outlining its new authentication option, the IRS said no biometric data would be required.
After the IRS made its announcement, the Massachusetts Department of Unemployment Assistance became the first state-level agency to follow suit and discontinue its use of facial recognition technology through ID.me. For its part, ID.me founder and Chief Executive Blake Hall said in a statement that the company’s shift away from the technology came after it “listened to the feedback about facial recognition.”
Privacy advocates want the effort to go further, however, and are seeking a complete governmental abandonment of the use of facial recognition technology. In an open letter, more than 40 organizations urged public agencies to “follow suit” given the privacy and civil liberties implications in using the technology, as well as its outsized impact on communities of color.
The groups also said the need to use facial recognition discriminates against those with some disabilities, or those who do not have reliable internet access.
The Feb. 25-27, 2022, survey was conducted among a representative sample of 2,004 registered voters, with an unweighted margin of error of plus or minus 2 percentage points.
