America’s Most and Least Popular Governors

Republicans continue to dominate, at the top and bottom of the rankings

Getty Images / Morning Consult Illustration by Czarina Divinagracia
  • Bill Walker (I-Alaska) is the least popular governor running for re-election this year, with net approval of -26%.

  • Walker posted the largest net slide in approval of any governor in the fourth quarter, falling 19 points compared to the previous quarter.

  • Gov. Rick Scott (R-Fla.), a potential contender for a Senate run, finished the year 7 points higher compared to prior quarter, with 27% net approval.

Most of the governors running for re-election this year ended 2017 in a strong position, according to Morning Consult’s Governor Approval Rankings.

The latest installment of the quarterly rankings — based on surveys with 253,393 registered voters nationwide conducted online from Oct. 1 through Dec. 31 — shows 10 of the 19 governors garnered the support of a majority of their constituents. (Full methodology is available here.)

Republicans control 33 of the country’s 50 governorships, and 13 of the state leaders running this year to keep their jobs hail from the GOP, including first-term Republicans in reliably blue states: Charlie Baker of Massachusetts (69 percent approval), Larry Hogan of Maryland (66 percent) and Phil Scott of Vermont (63 percent).

Popular GOP governors on the ballot this year in deep-red states are also in the top 10: Kay Ivey in Alabama (64 percent approval) and Asa Hutchinson in Arkansas and Greg Abbott in Texas, both with 59 percent approval.

Things look less rosy for Republican Govs. Bruce Rauner of Illinois and Scott Walker of Wisconsin, who both ended 2017 underwater — Rauner by 24 points (55 percent disapprove) and Walker by 7 points (50 percent disapprove).

A Republican-turned-independent, Bill Walker of Alaska, also finished last year in a weak position, as the 10th least popular, after posting the largest net slide (-19 percentage points) of any governor during the fourth quarter. Fifty-five percent of registered voters in Alaska disapproved of his work in office, compared with 29 percent who approved.

Among the five Democratic governors up for re-election this year, Andrew Cuomo of New York is more popular than his party colleagues, with 55 percent approving of his job performance. As the 11th least popular governor, Gina Raimondo of Rhode Island brings up the rear of the Democratic list, with 47 percent disapproval.

Meanwhile, half of the 16 governors who will head for the exits early next year found themselves among either the most popular or least popular in the fourth quarter of 2017.

Republicans Matt Mead of Wyoming and Brian Sandoval of Nevada were the fifth- and sixth-most popular governors that quarter, while Dennis Daugaard (R-S.D.) rounded out the top-10 list.

On the other end, Dan Malloy (D-Conn.), Mary Fallin (R-Okla.) and Susana Martinez (R-N.M.) were the second-, fourth- and fifth-least popular governors who are set to call it quits in 2019, followed by Maine Republican Paul LePage (8th-least popular) and Michigan’s Rick Snyder (10th-least popular).

The fourth quarter of 2017 also marked the final tally for three governors — Chris Christie (R-N.J.), Sam Brownback (R-Kan.) and Terry McAuliffe (D-Va.). Christie retained his title as the nation’s least popular governor during his last full quarter in office, while Brownback was again ranked the third least popular ahead of his confirmation to be an ambassador in the Trump administration.

McAuliffe was in the middle of the pack, with 15 percent net approval, during his final quarter as Virginia’s top Democrat.

  • Approve
  • Don't Know/Undecided
  • Disapprove

Stronger numbers for Scott, potential Senate candidate

Rick Scott, Florida’s Republican governor, is nearing the end of his second term and Republicans – including President Donald Trump – are trying to coax him into challenging Democratic Sen. Bill Nelson this year. Scott finished 2017 on an upswing (7 net points) in popularity in the Sunshine State compared to the prior quarter. Fifty-eight percent of voters in Florida approved of Scott during the fourth quarter, compared with 31 percent who disapproved.

Scott maintained strong support from GOP voters during the last six months of the year, from 79 percent in the third quarter to 82 percent the following three months. His approval numbers among independents also increased, from 47 percent to 53 percent, along with an 8-point gain among Democrats, during the same time period. In a Tuesday phone interview, Scott spokesman McKinley Lewis responded to questions about the governor’s interest in the Senate race by saying that the Florida Republican had not made a decision and was focused on finishing his work in office.

West Virginia’s Justice closes year strong after party switch

West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice (R) faced a turbulent first nine months of 2017 as he feuded with top Republicans in the state legislature during a protracted budget standoff. But the Aug. 3 announcement that he was rejoining the state’s GOP after roughly two years away — and his victory in pushing a referendum on a road bond plan that sailed through a special session in October — appear to work in his favor during the fourth quarter.

The former coal magnate improved his standing among Mountain State voters by 13 net percentage points between the third and fourth quarter of 2017, the largest increase Morning Consult recorded during that time frame.

Forty-seven percent of registered voters in West Virginia approved of Justice’s job performance during the final three months of the year, while 39 percent disapproved. He saw jumps in net approval among voters of all stripes, including 14 points among Democrats and 12 points among Republicans and independents.

StateGovernorApproveDisapproveDon't Know / No OpinionMargin of Error
AlabamaKay Ivey64%15%21%1%
AlaskaBill Walker29%55%15%6%
ArizonaDoug Ducey42%36%22%1%
ArkansasAsa Hutchinson59%23%19%2%
CaliforniaJerry Brown48%38%14%1%
ColoradoJohn Hickenlooper53%31%16%2%
ConnecticutDan Malloy23%68%9%2%
DelawareJohn Carney55%26%20%3%
FloridaRick Scott58%31%11%1%
GeorgiaNathan Deal56%24%20%1%
HawaiiDavid Ige46%38%17%4%
IdahoButch Otter51%34%15%3%
IllinoisBruce Rauner31%55%14%1%
IndianaEric Holcomb50%24%26%1%
IowaKim Reynolds44%29%27%2%
KansasSam Brownback24%64%12%2%
KentuckyMatt Bevin41%41%17%1%
LouisianaJohn Bel Edwards56%27%18%2%
MainePaul LePage42%53%6%3%
MarylandLarry Hogan66%18%17%2%
MassachusettsCharlie Baker69%16%15%1%
MichiganRick Snyder37%47%15%1%
MinnesotaMark Dayton52%33%15%2%
MississippiPhil Bryant51%29%20%2%
MissouriEric Greitens48%29%23%1%
MontanaSteve Bullock53%31%17%4%
NebraskaPete Ricketts54%28%18%3%
NevadaBrian Sandoval61%19%20%2%
New HampshireChris Sununu58%22%19%3%
New JerseyChris Christie19%76%5%1%
New MexicoSusana Martinez33%57%10%3%
New YorkAndrew Cuomo55%33%12%1%
North CarolinaRoy Cooper48%30%22%1%
North DakotaDoug Burgum57%22%21%4%
OhioJohn Kasich52%30%18%1%
OklahomaMary Fallin28%61%11%2%
OregonKate Brown45%37%17%2%
PennsylvaniaTom Wolf44%38%17%1%
Rhode IslandGina Raimondo40%47%12%3%
South CarolinaHenry McMaster52%23%25%2%
South DakotaDennis Daugaard59%31%10%4%
TennesseeBill Haslam55%24%21%1%
TexasGreg Abbott59%24%16%1%
UtahGary Herbert60%24%16%3%
VermontPhil Scott63%21%16%4%
VirginiaTerry McAuliffe47%32%21%1%
WashingtonJay Inslee50%31%20%1%
West VirginiaJim Justice47%39%14%2%
WisconsinScott Walker43%50%8%1%
WyomingMatt Mead63%24%14%5%

*Brownback, Christie and McAuliffe are no longer governors. They were in office during the fourth quarter of 2017.

Clarification: Scott’s spokesman specified in Tuesday’s interview that the governor has not made a decision regarding a potential Senate run.