Why Instacart Wins Grocery Delivery — but Struggles in Meal Moments

Leaders from the world’s largest companies, equity research firms, hedge funds, and the Federal Reserve rely on Morning Consult’s 30,000 daily survey interviews in 45 countries covering more than 5,000 brands, economic indicators, and risk metrics. Schedule a demo to access the always-on consumer signal.

Category Advantage measures the drivers of brand strength by capturing both mental availability (likelihood a brand comes to mind) and emotional closeness (how strongly consumers connect with a brand) among all competitors. Schedule a private briefing on this research. .

The bottom line up front  

Instacart is the category's grocery and essentials specialist. It dominates 'skip the grocery trip' and 'essentials delivered quickly' occasions—and under-indexes on meal-relief moments where restaurant aggregators lead. This positioning is both a defensive moat and an expansion constraint: Instacart wins when the job is household logistics, but has limited retrieval in impulsive, late-night, and social meal moments. The strategic priority is cementing household-first dominance while selectively testing meal-adjacent expansions through partnerships—not repositioning.

The Category Landscape

Food & beverage delivery is mentally structured around two distinct competitive lanes: restaurant-first aggregators (DoorDash, Uber Eats) and retail-native players (Instacart, Walmart+, Amazon Fresh). These are not direct substitutes in consumer memory—they solve different jobs.

DoorDash and Uber Eats dominate meal-relief occasions—'too busy to cook,' late-night, social moments. Instacart, Walmart+, and Amazon Fresh dominate household logistics—'skip the grocery trip,' 'essentials now,' planned replenishment. GoPuff and Shipt occupy narrower niches in convenience and same-day retail.

Instacart's strategic question: How does it defend and extend its grocery/essentials moat while selectively capturing meal-adjacent moments—without diluting core positioning or competing head-to-head with restaurant aggregators?

Instacart's memory network is tightly linked to household logistics and planned replenishment—a specialist advantage, not a generalist one.

Where Instacart Stands

The Good News

• Instacart dominates the grocery/essentials lane. Controlling for brand size, Instacart over-indexes on 'saving time by skipping the grocery store' (+14) and 'get essential items delivered quickly' (+16). This is habitual, plannable demand you monetize repeatedly through subscriptions and repeat orders.

• Specialist positioning is a moat, not a limitation. Instacart wins when the consumer's job is basket-building and household logistics. That's a different mental category than 'feed me now'—and it's defensible against restaurant aggregators who lack the inventory, merchant relationships, and fulfillment infrastructure to compete credibly.

• Household-heavy segments are natural Instacart territory. 35–44 year-olds and family households show the strongest CEPs for 'feeding the family on busy weekends' and 'skip the grocery store.' Instacart's brand already aligns to these. This is where subscription and loyalty investments have highest ROI.

• Immediacy is a winnable premium. Where operational density supports it, Instacart can own the 'essentials now' CEP through same-day and 1–2 hour delivery windows. This is a premium tier that maintains margin while building mental availability for urgency occasions.

The Challenge

Instacart's specialist strength is also an expansion constraint.

• Meal-relief CEPs belong to restaurant aggregators. Instacart under-indexes on late-night snacks, brunch, quick lunches, and 'too busy to cook' occasions. These gaps are structural—DoorDash and Uber Eats have the merchant coverage, speed expectations, and brand memory to own them. Trying to compete head-to-head is expensive and low-probability.

• Younger adults (21–34) use delivery for impulsive meals, not planned grocery runs. Instacart under-indexes here. Growth in this segment requires either partnerships (in-app meal add-ons) or behavioral nudges ('same-night essentials' during evening hours)—not repositioning.

• Walmart+ is a formidable competitor in the same lane. Walmart+ has structural advantages in price, assortment breadth, and physical footprint. Instacart competes on speed, curated assortment, and specialty items—but must avoid a price war it cannot win.

The Core Insight: Instacart's gaps in meal-relief CEPs are structural, not merely perceptual. They reflect merchant coverage, speed expectations, and the fundamental difference between 'feed me now' and 'stock my household.' That argues for product and partner fixes when expanding into meal-adjacent moments—not simply more creative. Play to your earnings-efficient strengths (household, subscriptions, repeat orders) while selectively testing authentic, low-risk expansions.

Who Uses Instacart Today

Strongest Segments (Defend and Reinforce)

• Ages 35–44 (household orchestrators): Strongest CEPs for 'feeding the family on busy weekends' and 'skip the grocery store.' These users value reliability, value certainty, and simple replenishment UX. Priority: product features that reduce planning friction—smart lists, repeat orders, family bundles.

• Family households: Instacart+ subscribers with children show highest repeat-order frequency and basket sizes. Emotional connection to the brand is driven by reliability and time savings. Priority: lock these users into subscription with family-specific benefits.

• Suburban markets with retail gaps: Where Walmart+ physical footprint is weak, Instacart can press its fulfillment advantage (faster windows, better inventory accuracy, specialty items). Use regional data to prioritize market-level investments.

Opportunity Segments (Extend Selectively)

• Younger adults (21–34): Under-index on Instacart; use delivery for impulsive meals more than planned grocery. Growth requires behavioral nudges ('same-night essentials' during evening hours) or partnerships (meal add-ons). Low-cost tests, not major repositioning.

• Urban density zones: Where operational density supports same-day/1–2 hour windows, Instacart can own the 'essentials now' CEP. Micro-fulfillment pilots in dense MSAs are the path—not broad expansion.

What Occasions Instacart Owns — and Where It's Exposed

Instacart's distinctive strength is household logistics and planned replenishment:

Where Instacart is relatively weaker (meal-relief occasions owned by restaurant aggregators):

These gaps are structural—restaurant aggregators have the merchant coverage and speed expectations to own them. Partnerships, not repositioning, are the path to capturing meal-adjacent moments.

Five strategic priorities for Instacart based on this research

1. Cement the 'household-first' position (core defense). Make Instacart synonymous with simple, fast household replenishment. 'Auto-Replenish' bundles for pantry staples, habit-building CRM ('Sunday restock' nudges), and product proofs (inventory accuracy guarantees, faster checkout for repeat baskets). KPI: increase CEP penetration for 'skip the grocery store' and repeat-order frequency among 35–44 households.

2. Monetize premium immediacy where you can win. Invest in same-day / 1–2 hour pick zones only where operational density supports profitability. Micro-fulfillment pilots in dense MSAs to own the 'need it now' essentials CEP. Premium guaranteed-window SKU clusters (baby, meds, beverages) that maintain margin. KPI: CEP lift for 'essentials delivered quickly' in test DMAs.

3. Strategic partnerships to capture meal moments without losing core identity. Rather than repositioning, partner (or API-integrate) with restaurant-first apps for frictionless add-ons. Checkout 'Add tonight's dinner' module powered by a restaurant aggregator partner, co-marketing bundles (grocery + meal combo discounts). Let Instacart capture incremental baskets when someone's primary job is a meal—without diluting household positioning.

4. Use Instacart+ to lock CEP links. Make Instacart+ the default for families and heavy users by tying it to CEP solves: free replacement, faster windows, repeat-order benefits, family-specific bundles. KPI: uplift in mental penetration among heavy users; NPS and emotional connection improvements for subscribers.

5. Measure success through household metrics, not meal-delivery comparisons. Track CEP penetration for 'skip grocery' and 'essentials quickly' (Total and 35–44 segment). Track repeat-order frequency and subscription penetration among heavy users. Don't benchmark against DoorDash's meal-relief share—benchmark against Walmart+ and Amazon Fresh in household logistics.

About this research

Morning Consult conducts over 30,000 daily proprietary surveys in 45 countries covering more than 5,000 brands and 50 economic indicators. 

Our category advantage research is aimed at understanding the needs driving consumers in your category — and how your brand can own more of them. This research is built on validated principles of brand-driven growth and powered by Morning Consult’s industry-leading sampling technology.

Measure the true drivers of brand strength

Capture both mental availability (the likelihood your brand comes to mind when consumers face a need or occasion) and emotional closeness (how strongly consumers connect with your brand), benchmarked against competitors.

Uncover Category Entry Points (CEPs)

Directly tied to mental availability, see the specific needs, occasions, and triggers that drive purchase decisions in your category, and how strongly your brand is linked to them.

Pinpoint growth opportunities

Direct investment toward the moments and consumer segments with the greatest potential to grow your brand.

Turn insights into action fast

Get survey results in 4–5 days through a centralized dashboard and short-form memo that equips stakeholders with clear direction on where and how to win.

Learn more